| 10:00am | Monday, April 23, 2012 | |||||||||
| 20110336 |
Richard J. Nichols as Trustee of the Richard
Nichols Mineral Trust Agreement dated May 28, 2009; Robby J. Nichols and Jacalyn Nichols; Kim Vachal as Trustee of the Ron and Sue Nichols Family Mineral Trust; JD Nichols LLLP; Randal B. And Bonnie L. Nichols Family LLP, Plaintiffs and Appellees v. James M. Goughnour, Individually and as Personal Representative of the Estate of Eunice Goughnour; LaDonna Edwards; Margo Wenzel and James Wenzel; Penny Edwards; Judy Nichols; Susan Trana; Mark Nichols; Serena Nichols; Darron Nichols; Earl R. Hauge and Ann M. Hauge; Rita Wagner, Wallace J. Wagner, Rudolph M. Maurer and Karlyn J. Maurer, as Trustees of the Rudolph M. And Karlyn J. Maurer Family Mineral Trust; Kathleen Yoder; Dale Wagner; Melissa Frederick; Nels Family, LLC; Robert Nichols; Robert E. Lincoln; Mary L. Lincoln; William F. Lincoln; Carol Nichols; Valera Marie Hayes; Alan Roger Sinclair; Elizabeth McDonald, aka Beth McDonald; Forrest John Spicher, aka Jon Spicher; Kelly Fulton; Kathryn Poskevich; Joan Hosler; Michael Miller; Barbara Linden; Bert Hague; Mike Nichols; Donnelle E. Nichols; Darrell Nichols; and all persons unknown, claiming any estate in or lien or encumbrance upon the property described in the Complaint, Defendants and Appellants | |||||||||
| Appeal from: | Northwest Judicial District, Mountrail County, Judge Gary H. Lee, 31-11-C-00028 | |||||||||
| Nature of Action: | Real Property | |||||||||
| Counsel: |
| |||||||||
| Issues: |
Appellant's Statement of the Issues: 1. The trial court erred in granting summary judgment for the plaintiff. 2. The trial court erred in determining the deeds were not ambiguous. 3. The trial court erred when it did not consider the eight family member deeds as a single transaction and ignored other compelling evidence and granted summary judgment. 4. The trial court erred when it rationalized "Duhig" instead of applying "Gilbertson". | |||||||||
| Briefs: |
| |||||||||
Generated from Supreme Court Docket on 05/03/2012 | ||||||||||