| 1889-92 | | Corliss, Guy C. H. |
| 1892-94 | | Bartholomew, Joseph M. |
| 1894-96 | | Wallin, Alfred |
| 1896-99 | | Corliss, Guy C. H. |
| 1899-1901 | | Bartholomew, Joseph M. |
| 1901-03 | | Wallin, Alfred |
| 1903-06 | | Young, Newton C. |
| 1906-11 | | Morgan, David E. |
| 1911-15 | | Spalding, Burleigh F. |
| 1915-17 | | Fisk, Charles J. |
| 1917-18 | | Bruce, Andrew A. |
| 1918-21 | | Christianson, Adolph M. |
| 1921 | | Robinson, James E. |
| 1921-22 | | Grace, Richard H. (became Chief Justice 09/01/21) |
| 1922-23 | | Birdzell, Luther E. (became Chief Justice 05/01/22) |
| 1923-25 | | Bronson, Harrison A. |
| 1925-27 | | Christianson, Adolph M. |
| 1927-28 | | Birdzell, Luther E. |
| 1928-29 | | Nuessle, William L. |
| 1929-31 | | Burke, John |
| 1931-33 | | Christianson, Adolph M. |
| 1933 | | Nuessle, William L. (01/01/33 to 09/01/33) |
| 1933 | | Birdzell, Luther E. (09/01/33 to 11/01/33) |
| 1933-35 | | Burr, Alexander G. (became Chief Justice 11/01/33) |
| 1935-37 | | Burke, John |
| 1937-39 | | Christianson, Adolph M. |
| 1939-41 | | Nuessle, William L. |
| 1941-43 | | Burr, Alexander G. |
| 1943-45 | | Morris, James |
| 1945-49 | | Christianson, Adolph M. |
| 1949-51 | | Nuessle, William L. |
| 1951-55 | | Morris, James |
| 1955-57 | | Burke, Thomas J. |
| 1957-59 | | Grimson, Gudmunder |
| 1959-63 | | Sathre, P. O. |
| 1963-65 | | Morris, James |
| 1965-66 | | Burke, Thomas J. (until his death 03/20/66) |
| 1966-67 | | Teigen, Obert C. |
| 1967 | | Strutz, Alvin C. (07/01/67 to 10/20/67) |
| 1967-71 | | Teigen, Obert C. |
| 1971-73 | | Strutz, Alvin C. (until his death 06/16/73) |
| 1973-92 | | Erickstad, Ralph J. |
| 1993- | | VandeWalle, Gerald W. |
|