Rist v. ND Dept. of Transportation
Robert Shawn Rist Petitioner and Appellee
North Dakota Department
of Transportation Respondent and Appellant
South Central Judicial District,
Judge Robert O. Wefald
|Nature of Action:||Transportation Dept.|
|Term:||02/2003  Argument: 02/26/2003|
|ND cite:||2003 ND 113|
665 N.W.2d 45
Listen to recording of oral argument in MP3 format
Appellant's Statement of the Issues:|
I. Whether the encounter between Rist and Deputy Messmer was justified.
II. Whether Rist failed to demonstrate grounds supporting remand for additional evidence.
Appellee's Statement of the Issues:
I. Whether probable cause existed for an officer to (a) command a person sleeping in a pick-up in a camping area to wake up, (b) reach into a pick-up in a camping area so that the officer can awaken that person; (c) command a person previously sleeping in his pick-up in a camping area to get out of the vehicle and get his driver's license from his camping gear in the back of his pick-up; and/or (d) arrest the person who is doing nothing more than sleeping in a pick-up - with no key anywhere to be found - in a camping area with or without a blood alcohol level above .10.
II. Whether, under the circumstances, sufficient evidence existed to suspend a driver's license based upon an allegation of "Actual Physical Control" where the record is devoid of even a scintilla of evidence that the vehicle in question was operable.
III. Whether this matter should be remanded on the issue of "operability" where counsel learned for the first time at the DOT hearing that there was no vehicle key anywhere to be found, and there is a substantial material question as to whether the vehicle was operable without a key and only an automotive expert could have meaningfully testified on that issue.
|Add Docket 20020303 RSS|
|1||10/28/2002 NOTICE OF APPEAL: 10/23/2002|
|2||10/29/2002 DISK - TRA Admin Hearing of 8-1-02|
|3||11/19/2002 RECORD ON APPEAL & separate No. 5 (Transcript of Testimony of Administrative Hearing dated 8-1-02)|
|4||11/27/2002 APPELLANT BRIEF|
|5||11/27/2002 APPELLANT APPENDIX|
|6||11/27/2002 DISK - ATB (e-mailed)|
|7||12/11/2002 SUPPLEMENTAL CLERK'S CERTIFICATE OF RECORD DATED DECEMBER 10, 2002 (Entries 18-23)|
|8||12/23/2002 APPELLEE BRIEF|
|9||12/24/2002 DISK - AEB|
|10||02/26/2003 APPEARANCES: Reid A. Brady; Chad C. Nodland|
|11||02/26/2003 ARGUED: Brady; Nodland (Vol. Y; Page 96)|
|12||02/26/2003 ORAL ARGUMENT WEBCAST|
|13||07/16/2003 DISPOSITION: REVERSED|
|14||07/16/2003 UNANIMOUS OPINION: VandeWalle, Gerald W.|
|15||07/16/2003 Costs on appeal taxed in favor of Appellant under Rule 39, N.D.R.App.P.|
|16||07/17/2003 Order/Judgment Mailed to Parties|
|18||08/12/2003 RECEIPT SIGNED BY DISTRICT COURT CLERK'S OFFICE|
|19||09/03/2008 EXPUNGED - Nonpermanent record items destroyed|