Gadeco v. Industrial Commission

20110131

Gadeco, LLC, Appellee
v.
Industrial Commission of the
State of North Dakota, Appellant
and
Slawson Exploration Company, Appellee

Appeal from:

District Court, Northwest Judicial District, Mountrail County
Judge Richard L. Hagar

Nature of Action:

Administrative Proceeding

Counsel:

Appellee:		Dennis Edward Johnson
Appellee:		Lawrence Bender
Appellee:		Amy Lynn De Kok
Appellant:		Charles M. Carvell , Att. General Office
Appellee:		Ariston Edward Johnson
Appellant:		Todd Adam Sattler

Term:

11/2011 Argument: 11/07/2011 01:30pm

ND cite:

2012 ND 33

NW cite:

812 N.W.2d 405

Listen to recording of oral argument
using RealPlayer Basic,^© a free download.

Issues:

Appellant's Statement of the Issues:
Did the North Dakota Industrial Commission appropriately conclude that, under its risk penalty rule, a risk penalty could be imposed on the Gadeco, LLC leasehold interests for the drilling and completion of the Coyote 1-32H well?

Add Docket 20110131 RSS

Docket entries:

1	05/05/2011	NOTICE OF APPEAL: 04/29/2011
2	05/12/2011	--------CONSOLIDATED w/20110140---------
3	05/13/2011	Transcript of Administrative Hearing dated 3-22-10
4	05/13/2011	MOT. EXT/TIME APPELLANT BRIEF (Sua Sponte): 06/19/2011
5	05/13/2011	ACTION BY CLERK (Sua Sponte). Granted: 06/19/2011
6	05/17/2011	Letter from Lawrence Bender dated 5-16-11 RE: no will not be a Rule 10 Transcript Order
7	05/27/2011	Electronic RECORD ON APPEAL (entry nos. 1 - 35)
8	06/07/2011	APPELLANT (State) BRIEF and Addendum
9	06/07/2011	APPELLANT APPENDIX (State)
10	06/07/2011	DISK - ATB (e-mail)
11	06/08/2011	MOT. EXT/TIME APPELLANT BRIEF (Slawson Exploration in 20110140) (e-filed)
12	06/08/2011	E-FILED MOTION (MAT of Slawson Exploration in 20110140)
13	06/08/2011	ACTION BY CLERK (MAT of Slawson Exploration in 20110140). Granted: 07/19/2011
14	06/09/2011	Supplemental Affidavit of Lawrence Bender in support of Mot/Ext/ATB (Slawson Expl)
15	06/09/2011	Rec'd corrections to ATB & ATA (State).
16	07/19/2011	Slawson's Appellant's Brief and Appellee's Brief & Addendum (e-filed)
17	07/19/2011	E-FILED BRIEF (Slawson ATB)
18	07/20/2011	Received $25 surcharge for Slawson Brief (Receipt #20568)
19	07/25/2011	Received 7 copies of Slawson's Brief and Addendum from CSD
20	07/26/2011	APPELLANT APPENDIX (Slawson Exploration)
21	07/26/2011	E-FILED APPENDIX (Slawson Exploration)
22	08/01/2011	Received 6 cc of ATA (Slawson Exploration) from Central Duplicating
23	08/12/2011	MOT. EXT/TIME APPELLEE BRIEF
24	08/12/2011	ACTION BY CLERK. Granted: 09/19/2011
25	08/12/2011	e-mail from Todd Sattler stating Charles Carvell, Asst. Attorney General, is handling the case
26	09/15/2011	APPELLEE BRIEF (Gadeco)
27	09/15/2011	E-FILED BRIEF - AEB (Gadeco)
28	09/15/2011	Rec'd $25.00 AEB (Gadeco) e-file surcharge. (receipt no. 20664)
29	09/20/2011	MOTION FOR Extention of time to file reply brief by ND Industrial Commission
30	09/20/2011	ACTION BY CLERK MOT/Ext/RYB by ND Industrial Commission. Granted: 10/17/2011
31	09/21/2011	Rec'd 7 copies of AEB (Gadeco) from Central Duplicating.
32	09/22/2011	MOTION FOR Extention of time to file reply brief by Slawson Exploration Company
33	09/22/2011	E-FILED MOTION (Motion for extension of Reply Brief)
34	09/23/2011	ACTION BY SUPREME COURT (Extension of time of Reply Brief by Slawson Exploration Company). Granted: 10/17/2011
35	10/05/2011	NOTICE OF ORAL ARGUMENT SENT
36	10/17/2011	REPLY BRIEF of Industrial Commission
37	10/17/2011	DISK - ryb (Industrial Commission)
38	10/18/2011	REPLY BRIEF of Slawson Exploration Co. (e-filed)
39	10/18/2011	E-FILED BRIEF (RYB of Slawson Exploration)
40	10/18/2011	Gray covers for RYB of Industrial Commission
41	10/24/2011	Received 7 copies of RYB of Slawson Exploration from CSD
42	11/07/2011	APPEARANCES: Charles M. Carvell; Lawrence Bender; Dennis E. Johnson; Ariston E. Johnson
43	11/07/2011	ARGUED: Charles M. Carvell; Lawrence Bender; Ariston E. Johnson
44	11/07/2011	ORAL ARGUMENT WEBCAST
45	01/25/2012	SUPPLEMENTAL RECORD ON APPEAL dated January 23, 2012 (entry no. 6, TRA Admin. Record).
46	01/25/2012	E-mail from Todd Sattler stating he is not longer representing appellants.
47	02/17/2012	DISPOSITION: REVERSED AND REMANDED
48	02/17/2012	UNANIMOUS OPINION: VandeWalle, Gerald W.
49	02/17/2012	At Court's direction, no costs will be taxed in this appeal
50	02/22/2012	Judgment Sent to Parties
51	03/21/2012	MANDATE
52	03/26/2012	RECEIPT SIGNED BY DISTRICT COURT CLERK'S OFFICE

Generated from Supreme Court Docket on 05/17/2013