Search Tips

State of ND ex rel. Heitkamp v. Quill Corp.

Docket No. 19900257
Oral Argument: Tuesday, December 18, 1990 11:00AM

Docket Info

Title
State of North Dakota, by and
through its Tax Commissioner,
Heidi Heitkamp, Plaintiff, Appellant and
Cross-Appellee
v.
Quill Corporation, Defendant, Appellee and
Cross-Appellant
Case Type
CIVIL APPEAL : TAX RELATED
Appeal From
Case No. 41677
South Central Judicial District, Burleigh County
Benny A. Graff

Highlight

Briefs

Filing Date Description
08/06/1990 APPELLANT BRIEF
09/24/1990 APPELLEE BRIEF (w/ attached Addendum - expunged)
10/23/1990 REPLY BRIEF (APPELLANT)
11/05/1990 REPLY BRIEF (Quill Corp.) (DISTRIBUTE w/DEC. CALENDAR)

Counsel

Party Type Name
APPELLANT STATE AGENCY Robert W Wirtz - 02876
APPELLANT SPEC. ASST. ATTY. GEN. Not Licensed in ND - 00002
APPELLEE PRIVATE PRACTICE Not Licensed in ND - 00002
APPELLANT STATE AGENCY Joy Laurel Wezelman - 03697
APPELLANT ATTY. GENERAL OFFICE Nicholas J Spaeth - 03647

(Note: Attachments may not be available for recently filed cases and/or confidential documents.)

Seq. # Filing Date Description Attachment
1 06/28/1990 NOTICE OF APPEAL : 06/27/1990
2 07/06/1990 NOTICE OF CROSS APPEAL
3 07/30/1990 RECORD ON APPEAL, Exhibits and Transcripts (2)
4 08/06/1990 APPELLANT BRIEF
5 08/06/1990 APPELLANT APPENDIX (with 2 separately bound attachments)
6 09/24/1990 MOT. EXT/TIME APPELLEE BRIEF & Aff/Support
7 09/24/1990 MOT. EXT/TIME APPELLEE BRIEF & Aff/Support
8 09/24/1990 ACTION BY DEPUTY CLERK - GRANTED : 09/24/1990
9 09/24/1990 APPELLEE BRIEF (w/ attached Addendum - expunged)
10 10/09/1990 MOT. EXT/TIME REPLY BRIEF & AFF/SUPPORT
11 10/09/1990 ACTION BY CLERK - GRANTED : 10/10/1990
12 10/09/1990 MOT. EXT/TIME REPLY BRIEF & AFF/SUPPORT
13 10/09/1990 ACTION BY CLERK - GRANTED : 10/23/1990
14 10/23/1990 REPLY BRIEF (APPELLANT)
15 11/05/1990 REPLY BRIEF (Quill Corp.) (DISTRIBUTE w/DEC. CALENDAR)
16 12/07/1990 AFFIDAVITS OF GOOD STANDING (JOHN E. GAGGINI & DON S. HARNACK
17 12/10/1990 REQUEST FOR TV COVERAGE (KFYR-TV) GRANTED
18 12/18/1990 APPEARANCES: The Hon. Nicholas J. Spaeth, Attorney General;
19 12/18/1990 John E. Gaggini, Don S. Harnack and William P. Pearce
20 12/18/1990 Alan Friedman, Special Asst. Attny. General also present
21 12/18/1990 ARGUED: Spaeth; Gaggini (Vol. S, pg. 54)
22 12/18/1990 (IN OPEN COURT: Atty. Gen. Spaeth was requested to
23 12/18/1990 supplement his briefs and respond to the last full
24 12/18/1990 paragraph on page 16 of the Appellee's Brief within five
25 12/18/1990 days. Appellees will respond to the supplemental filing
26 12/18/1990 five days after service.)
27 12/21/1990 Letter dated 12-18-90 from Nicholas Spaeth (in response to
28 12/21/1990 questions asked by Court during OA) (copies distributed)
29 12/24/1990 Letter dated 12/22/90 from William P. Pearce (copies dist.)
30 02/05/1991 MOTION TO CITE SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY
31 02/22/1991 ACTION BY CHIEF JUSTICE (VandeWalle) - GRANTED
32 02/08/1991 Letter dated February 4, 1991, regarding SFA Folio Collec-
33 02/08/1991 tions v. Bannon (217 Conn. 220, (January 21, 1991))
34 02/13/1991 (NOTE: Court accepted the above letter for filing)
35 02/22/1991 MOTION TO CITE SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY
36 02/22/1991 ACTION BY CHIEF JUSTICE (VandeWalle) - GRANTED
37 03/12/1991 Letter from Joy Wezelman dated 3/12/91 with copies of two
38 03/12/1991 recent trial court decisions from the State of Tennessee
39 03/12/1991 (copies made and distributed to Justices)
40 05/07/1991 DISPOSITION
41 05/07/1991 UNANIMOUS OPINION : VandeWalle, Gerald W.
42 05/07/1991 Costs on appeal taxed in favor of appellant
43 05/16/1991 Corrected cover page for opinion (added Mr. Friedman)
44 05/16/1991 the above sent to West, Mead Data & Commerce
45 05/30/1991 MANDATE
46 08/08/1991 NOTICE OF FILING PETITION FOR CERTIORARI US SUPREME COURT
47 11/01/1991 Sent Brief, Appendix, Judgment, Opinion to U.S. Supreme Ct.
48 05/28/1992 Received copy of the U.S. Supreme Court Opinion which
49 05/28/1992 reversed and remanded our Court
50 06/29/1992 MANDATE FOR UNITED STATES SUPREME COURT
51 07/22/1992 MOTION TO PROVIDE SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEFING
52 10/01/1992 ACTION BY SUPREME COURT (Pet/Rehearing) - GRANTED
53 07/28/1992 DISPOSITION (Opinion rendered May 7, 1991, is vacated and
54 07/28/1992 the judgment of the district court is affirmed)
55 07/28/1992 UNANIMOUS OPINION : VandeWalle, Gerald W.
56 10/01/1992 -------SEE SUPREME COURT NO. 920283 FOR THE FOLLOWING--------
57 10/01/1992 ------------------DOCUMENTS---------------------------------
58 07/29/1992 PETITION FOR REHEARING (Quill Corp.)
59 08/12/1992 Letter dated 8-10-92 from William P. Pearce stating there is
60 08/12/1992 now a pending Petition for Rehearing and Correction Judg-
61 08/12/1992 ment filed by Quill Corp. in response to Judgment on
62 08/12/1992 7-29-92
63 08/27/1992 Court requested simultaneous briefs on the issue of whether
64 08/27/1992 or not the Quill Corp. is entitled to attorneys' fees
65 08/27/1992 under 42 U.S.C. Subsections 1983 and 1988 in view of the
66 08/27/1992 fact that the U.S. Sup.Ct. reversed "National Bellas Hess,
67 08/27/1992 Inc. v. Dept. of Revenue of Ill.
68 09/18/1992 Supplemental Brief Regarding Attys Fees w/ Appendix A,B & C
69 09/18/1992 filed by Quill Corporation
70 09/18/1992 Brief regarding attys fees filed by State of ND
71 10/01/1992 ACTION BY SUPREME COURT (Pet/Rehearing) - GRANTED
72 10/01/1992 (Ct. ordered that a hearing be scheduled for the
73 10/01/1992 Nov. Term of Court--case has been assigned a new number.
74 10/01/1992 See Supreme Court No. 920283)
75 04/24/2001 EXPUNGED - Nonpermanent record items destroyed